Amazon
'We Were Liars' Book vs. Series: Amazon Prime Video Adaptation Adds New Drama and Affairs
The highly anticipated series adaptation of "We Were Liars" is now available for streaming on Amazon Prime Video, offering a fresh take on E. Lockhart’s bestselling novel. This new series diverges from the original book in several key ways, injecting additional layers of drama and intrigue into an already complex narrative.
Compressing Time: A Shift in the Sinclair Family's Summers
The series makes a significant alteration to the timeline of the story, condensing events that span multiple summers in the book into just the summers of 16 and 17. This change allows for a faster-paced series that intensifies the drama and focuses sharply on the pivotal moments in the Sinclair family's life.
The Sinclair family, affluent and enigmatic, traditionally spends its summers on Beechwood, a fictional island off the coast of Martha’s Vineyard. The series maintains this setting, providing a picturesque yet haunting backdrop for the unfolding drama. The lush island scenery contrasts sharply with the underlying tensions and secrets that threaten to unravel the Sinclair clan.
New Dimensions: Johnny's Character and School Drama
One of the most notable changes in the series is the portrayal of Johnny, played by Joseph Zada. The character is depicted as gay, adding a new layer to his storyline. Johnny's journey includes a brief coming out moment and multiple romantic entanglements throughout the series, expanding his role beyond what was initially portrayed in the book.
Johnny's storyline also includes a dramatic incident at school where he gets into a violent altercation, resulting in another student being hospitalized. This event leads to his mother intervening financially to resolve the situation quietly, illustrating the lengths the Sinclair family will go to maintain their pristine image.
Confrontations and Affairs: Unfolding Family Drama
The series does not shy away from addressing contentious topics. Cady, one of the central characters, directly confronts her grandfather, Harris Sinclair, over his racist remarks. This confrontation marks a significant deviation from the book, highlighting Cady's active role in challenging and addressing her family's problematic behaviors.
Another addition to the series is the character Bess, who engages in an affair with a harbor service worker known as 'Salty Dan' during summer 16. This affair causes significant tension within the family and becomes a pivotal point in the inheritance disputes that plague the Sinclair family.
Mirren, one of the Sinclair sisters, also navigates her own complicated relationships. She begins summer 16 by sexting with a prep school boy and later claims to have a romantic involvement with a seafarer named 'Drake Loggerhead.' However, she eventually admits to fabricating the relationship to impress her peers, adding a layer of deception to her character's arc.
The Tease of a Sequel: Hints at Future Developments
The conclusion of season 1 leaves viewers on a cliffhanger, with Cady coming to the harrowing realization that she is the sole survivor of a fire set by her cousins. This dramatic ending sets the stage for a potential second season, which is hinted at by the Sinclair sisters in the series.
The teased storyline for a second season involves "Family of Liars," suggesting that the series will delve deeper into the Sinclair family's intricate web of secrets and lies. Additionally, the character Johnny is depicted as being stuck in an "in-between" state, potentially indicating unresolved issues that could be explored in future episodes.
The series adaptation of "We Were Liars" on Amazon Prime Video offers an engaging and dramatic reinterpretation of E. Lockhart’s novel. By introducing new elements and character developments, the series provides both fans of the book and new viewers with a fresh perspective on the Sinclair family's turbulent summers on Beechwood Island.